Homocysteine and cholesterol
While most people have an idea that cholesterol is an undesirable fat which is somehow linked to heart disease few people have heard of Homocysteine, an amino acid (amino acids are the building blocks which make up proteins). The Times Newspaper, 17-7-1997, reported that Homocysteine is a more important risk factor than raised cholesterol for heart attack, stroke or peripheral artery obstruction. They reported high levels may be genetic or due to a diet low in Folic acid, vitamin B12 or B6. They go on to say that although a rich persons diet may be higher in fats it is also higher in folic acid, and this may explain why the poor have a higher rate of heart disease than rich people. They quote the British Medical Journal as recommending Folic acid be added to wheat flour, a measure already taken in the USA.
Homocysteine was discovered by Dr Kilmer Mc Kully about 1970. He is a pathologist in a large hospital where his job includes finding out the cause of death of patients. Back in the 1970’s he wondered how children could die of heart disease. Eventually he found high levels of Homocysteine in these children explaining the abnormality. He then wondered, being as the children developed what we normally think of as an older persons disease, whether some older people actually had raised Homocysteine developing later in life. He found this to be the case. As homocysteine rises so do cardiovascular related problems.
What is Homocysteine?
Homocysteine is an intermediary amino acid, let me explain. Suppose you want to travel from London to Brighton but always end up half way in Crawley – you did not get where you wanted to. In the body Homocysteine has no useful functions other than it is a necessary intermediary between Cysteine and Methionine (analogy Crawley); which have important functions. In some cases of nutritional or genetic deficiency the body is unable to convert cysteine to methionine, getting stuck at Homocysteine which has inflammatory effects particularly in the artery wall. Inflammation of the artery wall encourages plaque formation (plaques contain cholesterol), called arteriosclerosis, or hardening of the arteries.
Signs of arteriosclerosis include angina, breathlessness on mild exertion and cramping pains in the calf muscles after mild exercise, which goes away quickly on resting. Arteriosclerosis increases the likelihood of stroke or heart attack by making more clots. Dementia is also linked to high Homocysteine levels. The conversion of Homocysteine into cysteine or methionine relies on enzyme pathways which are genetically determined- you are born with the tendency. This explains why heart and circulatory problems run in families. Research by Dr Bruce Ames published in 2001 in the Journal of Clinical Nutrition adds that the genetic tendency may in theory be overcome by taking extra vitamins and minerals. Genes may only account for a minor part of our health with lifestyle being much more important. It’s not what you’ve got it’s what you do with it that counts more. Studies of identical twins supports this statement.
The key vitamins and minerals involved and some selected sources
Magnesium – found in Soya, Nuts, organic blackstrap molasses, wholemeal* grains and rice.
B6 –found in wholemeal* grains, Oats, Soya. Tuna, Turkey, Beef, Chicken, Salmon, Sweet potato, Potato, Sunflower seeds, Spinach, Banana
Folic acid –found in Soya, wholemeal* grains and cereals, Seeds, Nuts, dark green vegetables, Peas and legumes, Beets, Asparagus, Broccoli, Citrus fruits, Avocado, Caulflower, Corn
B12 – found in liver, meat, eggs, cheese, yoghurt, yeast extract, fortified cereals, many soya products, (miso and tempeh are not true sources).
Choline, and its derivatives DMG, TMG also found in liver, egg, wholemeal* foods and green vegetables.
Iodine, found in all fish, iodised sea salt and seaweeds. UK intake of Iodine is usually below the RDA while Japanese people who eat seaweed daily may have a hundred times our RDA in their daily diet. Buy a bag of seagreens in a health food store and start putting a few teaspoons in your soups or stews, think of it like mixed herbs. *Wholemeal: most people are better avoiding modern wheat and using spelt or other grains. Spelt is “Roman army bread” it was the daily bread of 2000 years ago; most people are OK to eat this grain but it does have gluten in it so no use to coeliacs.
Supplements: I recommend the use of specific vitamin and mineral formulas but need to test these in a consultation to know which ones work best for a given individual. In the absence of this find the best multi formula you can containing all the listed supplemets in this essay. ALso read my essay “Design your own nutrional program” in this articles section of the web-site. For proven high homocysteine levels there are specialist formulas such as TMG (also called betaine). Testing can be done by AK or blood test, Kilmer McKully says normal blood levels should be under 6. The British Medical Assocation says under 15, I suspect Dr McKully’s level is correct.
But what about cholesterol?
Cholesterol is the building block used to make most hormones. In my opinion I suspect cholesterol accumulates due to a lack of vitamin and mineral co-factors needed to convert it into these hormones. Possibly this conversion may also be blocked due to heavy metals in the body. Diet only accounts for 4% of our cholesterol levels, the rest we make. If we lack certain hormones maybe the body, makes more cholesterol to try and get more hormones made. Vitamin B3 encourages cholesterol conversion into pregnenolone from which hormones are made, but beware it can cause temporary (for 30 minutes usually) and harmless flushing. This effect can be reduced or eliminated by taking a baby aspirin 30 minutes before the B3 and in any case you get used to the B3 flush after about a month. Flush free niacin is made by some manufacturers including those above.
To lower cholesterol naturally:
- Avoid animal products, they are the only dietary source of cholesterol. Watch out for your B12 though if you are a vegetarian, see above.
- Eat soya products unless sensitive and fish.
- Try Policosanol from NUTRI as CHOLAREST a natural statin
- Eat Garlic
- Eat red yeast if your levels are very high– a natural statin
- If you choose to take any statin, supplement also with Co-enzyme Q10, super ubiquinol which is lowered by statins and vital for energy levels. Many people stop taking statins due to experiencing fatigue subsequent to starting it.
- Take 1 gram of non acidic vitamin C daily – maybe more, to aid excretion of cholesterol by the liver – liver problems may be the cause of raised cholesterol.
- Non-flush niacin – needs recommendation of practitioner.
- Hydration: dehydration may cause a rise in cholesterol to absorb acidity according to some writers. 1-3 litres a day according to weight, temperature and activity.
Your Own research
Try the www.lef.org for the latest information. Also read Dean Ornish MD’ s book ‘Reversing Heart disease without drugs or surgery’
NB Disclaimer: No one should rely on this or any other essay to make dietary changes without checking with their doctor or health advisor. We are all individuals and it is therefore it is best if everyone consults with a nutritional specialist, or naturopath to ascertain their own special needs. We are not responsible for persons we have not seen personally or if you choose to make changes without checking with your doctor or advisor.